1854 to 1857 - Rev. Michael Herzog

1857 to 1860 - Rev. Charles Schafroth

1860 to 1877 - Rev. Francis Grome

1877 to 1879 - Rev. Bernard Hillebrand

1879 to 1886 - Rev. William Cassander

1886 to 1904 - Rev. Stephan Schmid

1904 to 1931 - Rev. Bernard Greifenkamp

1931 to 1959 - Rev. Hubert Schmitz

1960 to 1965 - Rev. Msgr. John Walsh

1966 to 1980 - Rev. Charles Donovan

1980 to 1983 - Rev. Carl Schaffer

1983 to 1992 - Rev. Charles Garvey

1992 to 2004 - Rev. Michael Comer

2004 to 2006 - Rev. Richard W. Frazier